| | Day | Time | | Opponent | Score | | | Record |
| August |
| % | 16 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Alumni | L-1-3 | | | |
| % | 18 | 6:00 PM | vs. | Robert Morris College-Lake County | W-4-0 | | | |
| % | 20 | 6:00 PM | vs. | College of Lake County | W-5-0 | | | |
| | 22 | 1:30 PM | vs. | Cornerstone University | L-0-3 | | | 0-1 |
| | University of Michigan-Dearborn Tournament |
| | | 4:00 PM | vs. | Madonna University | W-2-1 (OT) | | | 1-1 |
| | | 6:30 PM | vs. | Notre Dame College | L-0-3 | | | 1-2 |
| | University of Michigan-Dearborn Tournament |
| | 23 | 9:00 AM | vs. | Spring Arbor University | L-0-3 | | | 1-3 |
| | University of Michigan-Dearborn Tournament |
| % | | 12:00 PM | vs. | Taylor University | W-3-2 | | | |
| | scrimmage |
| | | 3:00 PM | vs. | Davenport University | W-5-0 | | | 2-3 |
| | | 3:15 PM | vs. | Davenport University | L-2-3 | | | 2-4 |
| | University of Michigan-Dearborn Tournament |
| * | 26 | 7:00 PM | vs. | Illinois Institute of Technology | L-1-3 | | | 2-5 0-1 |
| | 29 | 2:00 PM | vs. | Mount Mercy University | W-3-2 | | | 3-5 |
| | Judson Tournament |
| | | 2:30 PM | vs. | Cornerstone University | L-1-2 | | | 3-6 |
| | Cornerstone University Tournament |
| | | 4:15 PM | vs. | University of Saint Francis | L-1-3 | | | 3-7 |
| | Judson Tournament |
| | | 7:00 PM | vs. | Graceland University | L-0-1 | | | 3-8 |
| | Grandview College Tournament |
| | 30 | 10:00 AM | vs. | University of Michigan-Dearborn | L-0-3 | | | 3-9 |
| | Judson Tournament |
| | | 1:00 PM | vs. | Walsh University | L-7-31 | | | 3-10 |
| | | 2:00 PM | vs. | Bethel College | L-1-3 | | | 3-11 |
| | Judson Tournament |
| | | 3:00 PM | vs. | Davenport University | L-0-4 | | | 3-12 |
| | Cornerstone University Tournament |
| | | 5:00 PM | vs. | Grand View University | W-3-2 (2OT) | | | 4-12 |
| | Grandview College Tournament |
| September |
| * | 2 | 7:00 PM | @ | Trinity Christian College | L-0-3 | | | 4-13 0-2 |
| * | 3 | 4:00 PM | @ | St. Francis | W-5-1 | | | 5-13 1-2 |
| | 5 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Saint Ambrose University | L-0-3 | | | 5-14 |
| | St. Xavier/Illinois Institute of Technology Tournament |
| | | 4:00 PM | vs. | Hope College | L-1-2 | | | 5-15 |
| | | 6:00 PM | vs. | Goshen College | W-3-1 | | | 6-15 |
| | St. Xavier/Illinois Institute of Technology Tournament |
| | | 7:00 PM | @ | Lindsey Wilson | L-0-5 | | | 6-16 |
| | 6 | 12:00 PM | @ | University of Saint Francis | L-0-67 | | | 6-17 |
| | | 12:30 PM | vs. | Cornerstone University | L-1-3 | | | 6-18 |
| | St. Xavier/Illinois Institute of Technology Tournament |
| | | 1:00 PM | @ | Georgetown College | W-1-0 | | | 7-18 |
| | | 2:30 PM | vs. | Bethel College | W-3-1 | | | 8-18 |
| | St. Xavier/Illinois Institute of Technology Tournament |
| | | 4:00 PM | vs. | Calvin College | L-1-5 | | | 8-19 |
| * | 9 | 7:00 PM | vs. | Olivet Nazarene University | L-0-3 | | | 8-20 1-3 |
| | 12 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Bethel College | W-2-1 | | | 9-20 |
| | Cedarville University Tournament (games moved to Xenia, OH at AIA complex) |
| | 13 | 2:00 PM | vs. | Indiana Wesleyan University | RAIN | | | |
| | | 3:30 PM | vs. | Southern Wesleyan University | L-2-4 | | | 9-21 |
| | Cedarville University Tournament (games moved to Xenia, OH at AIA complex) |
| * | 16 | 7:00 PM | @ | Saint Xavier University | L-0-3 | | | 9-22 1-4 |
| | 19 | 2:00 PM | vs. | Campbellsville University | L-1-3 | | | 9-23 |
| | Taylor University Tournament |
| | | 4:00 PM | vs. | Mount Vernon Nazarene College | L-1-3 | | | 9-24 |
| | Taylor University Tournament |
| | 20 | 11:30 AM | vs. | Davenport University | L-0-3 | | | 9-25 |
| | Taylor University Tournament |
| | | 1:00 PM | @ | Lincoln University | W-18-10 | | | 10-25 |
| | | 2:00 PM | vs. | Northland Baptist Bible College | W-3-0 | | | 11-25 |
| | | 3:30 PM | vs. | Spring Arbor University | W-3-2 | | | 12-25 |
| | Taylor University Tournament |
| * | 23 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Olivet Nazarene University | T-0-0 (2OT) | | | 12-25-1 1-4-1 |
| * | | 7:00 PM | vs. | University of Saint Francis | W-3-0 | | | 13-25-1 2-4-1 |
| * | 24 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Olivet Nazarene University | W-2-1 | | | 14-25-1 3-4-1 |
| * | 27 | 11:30 AM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | L-0-3 | | | 14-26-1 3-5-1 |
| | | 1:00 PM | vs. | Saint Xavier University | L-0-56 | | | 14-27-1 |
| * | | 2:30 PM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | L-0-1 | | | 14-28-1 3-6-1 |
| * | 30 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Calumet College of St. Joseph | W-16-0 | | | 15-28-1 4-6-1 |
| * | | 7:00 PM | @ | Purdue University-North Central | W-3-2 | | | 16-28-1 5-6-1 |
| October |
| * | 1 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Calumet College of St. Joseph | W-3-1 | | | 17-28-1 6-6-1 |
| * | 4 | 11:30 AM | vs. | Judson College | W-2-0 | | | 18-28-1 7-6-1 |
| | TIU Homecoming |
| * | | 1:00 PM | vs. | William Penn University | L-24-25 | | | 18-29-1 7-7-1 |
| * | | 2:00 PM | vs. | Judson College | L-0-1 | | | 18-30-1 7-8-1 |
| | TIU Homecoming |
| * | 7 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Cardinal Stritch University | L-0-2 | | | 18-31-1 7-9-1 |
| * | | 7:00 PM | vs. | Calumet College of St. Joseph | W-3-0 | | | 19-31-1 8-9-1 |
| * | 8 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Cardinal Stritch University | W-6-0 | | | 20-31-1 9-9-1 |
| | 10 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Elmhurst College | L-0-3 | | | 20-32-1 |
| | North Central College Tournament |
| | | 4:00 PM | vs. | Cornerstone University | W-3-0 | | | 21-32-1 |
| | | 6:00 PM | vs. | Tri-State University | W-3-2 | | | 22-32-1 |
| | North Central College Tournament |
| | 11 | 12:00 PM | vs. | St. Norbert College | L-0-3 | | | 22-33-1 |
| | North Central College Tournament |
| * | | 1:00 PM | @ | McKendree University | L-3-35 | | | 22-34-1 9-10-1 |
| | | 2:00 PM | vs. | North Central College | W-3-1 | | | 23-34-1 |
| | North Central College Tournament |
| * | 14 | 7:00 PM | @ | Robert Morris University | W-3-1 | | | 24-34-1 10-10-1 |
| * | | 7:30 PM | @ | Illinois Institute of Technology | W-3-0 | | | 25-34-1 11-10-1 |
| * | 15 | 7:00 PM | @ | Illinois Institute of Technology | L-0-3 | | | 25-35-1 11-11-1 |
| * | 18 | 11:00 AM | @ | Saint Xavier University | W-1-0 | | | 26-35-1 12-11-1 |
| * | | 1:30 PM | @ | Saint Xavier University | W-1-0 | | | 27-35-1 13-11-1 |
| * | | 6:00 PM | @ | Olivet Nazarene University | L-14-44 | | | 27-36-1 13-12-1 |
| * | 21 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Robert Morris University | W-4-0 | | | 28-36-1 14-12-1 |
| * | 22 | 3:30 PM | vs. | Robert Morris University | T-0-0 (2OT) | | | 28-36-2 14-12-2 |
| % | 23 | 7:00 PM | @ | East-West University | W-85-82 | | | |
| | 24 | 5:00 PM | vs. | Walsh University | L-0-3 | | | 28-37-2 |
| | Madonna University Tournament |
| | | 7:00 PM | vs. | University of Michigan-Dearborn | L-2-3 | | | 28-38-2 |
| | Madonna University Tournament |
| | 25 | 9:30 AM | vs. | Madonna University | L-1-3 | | | 28-39-2 |
| | Madonna University Tournament |
| | | 11:30 AM | vs. | Taylor University | L-0-3 | | | 28-40-2 |
| | Madonna University Tournament |
| * | | 12:00 PM | @ | University of Saint Francis | W-4-1 | | | 29-40-2 15-12-2 |
| * | | 1:00 PM | vs. | Iowa Wesleyan College | L-14-24 | | | 29-41-2 15-13-2 |
| | | 7:00 PM | @ | University of Illinois at Springfield | T-2-2 (2OT) | | | 29-41-3 |
| * | 28 | 7:00 PM | vs. | Judson College | W-3-1 | | | 30-41-3 16-13-2 |
| | 29 | 7:00 PM | vs. | McKendree University | L-79-99 | | | 30-42-3 |
| | 31 | 2:30 PM | vs. | Judson College | W-2-0 | | | 31-42-3 |
| | CCAC Quarter Final |
| | | 3:00 PM | vs. | University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point | W-3-1 | | | 32-42-3 |
| | University of Wisconsin-Whitewater Tournament |
| | | 5:00 PM | vs. | Lakeland College | L-1-3 | | | 32-43-3 |
| | University of Wisconsin-Whitewater Tournament |
| | | 7:00 PM | @ | University of Saint Francis | L-75-90 | | | 32-44-3 |
| | St. Francis IN Tourney |
| November |
| | 1 | | @ | Olivet Nazarene University | L-69-72 | | | 32-45-3 |
| | St. Francis IN Tourney |
| | | 11:00 AM | vs. | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | L-2-3 | | | 32-46-3 |
| | University of Wisconsin-Whitewater Tournament |
| * | | 1:00 PM | @ | Quincy University | L-9-28 | | | 32-47-3 16-14-2 |
| | | 1:30 PM | @ | Judson College | L-1-2 | | | 32-48-3 |
| | CCAC Tournament - Quarter Final |
| | | 3:00 PM | vs. | Concordia Wisconsin | L-2-3 | | | 32-49-3 |
| | University of Wisconsin-Whitewater Tournament |
| | | 5:00 PM | vs. | Mount Mercy University | L-49-58 | | | 32-50-3 |
| * | 4 | 7:00 PM | @ | Cardinal Stritch University | W-3-2 | | | 33-50-3 17-14-2 |
| | 5 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Robert Morris University | T-2-2 (2OT) | | | 33-50-4 |
| | CCAC Semi-finals TIU Wins 3-2 in Shootout |
| | | 7:00 PM | @ | McHenry County College | L-45-105 | | | 33-51-4 |
| | 7 | 4:00 PM | @ | Grace College | L-54-69 | | | 33-52-4 |
| | | 6:00 PM | @ | Grace College | L-65-73 | | | 33-53-4 |
| | 8 | 12:00 PM | vs. | Saint Xavier University | L-0-1 (OT) | | | 33-54-4 |
| | CCAC Finals |
| * | | 1:00 PM | vs. | University of Saint Francis | L-3-28 | | | 33-55-4 17-15-2 |
| | MSFA Midwest League |
| | | 1:00 PM | @ | University of Wisconsin Manitowoc | L-70-76 | | | 33-56-4 |
| | 10 | 6:00 PM | @ | Illinois Institute of Technology | W-74-58 | | | 34-56-4 |
| | 11 | 7:00 PM | @ | Illinois Institute of Technology | L-0-3 | | | 34-57-4 |
| | CCAC Quaterfinals |
| | | 7:00 PM | @ | Cornerstone University | L-74-83 | | | 34-58-4 |
| | 12 | 5:00 PM | @ | Trinity Christian College | L-70-77 | | | 34-59-4 |
| | 13 | 7:00 PM | @ | Rock Valley College | L-63-85 | | | 34-60-4 |
| | 14 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | W-3-0 | | | 35-60-4 |
| | NCCAA Regional Tournament (TIU qualifies for NCCAA National Tournament) |
| | | 5:00 PM | @ | Viterbo University | L-66-73 | | | 35-61-4 |
| | Viterbo Tournament |
| * | 15 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Saint Ambrose University | L-0-28 | | | 35-62-4 17-16-2 |
| | Live Stats |
| | | 1:00 PM | vs. | Olivet Nazarene University | L-1-4 | | | 35-63-4 |
| | NCCAA Regional Tournament |
| | | 1:00 PM | @ | Indiana Wesleyan University | L-35-40 | | | 35-64-4 |
| | Viterbo Tournament |
| | 17 | 7:00 PM | vs. | Benedictine University | W-66-63 | | | 36-64-4 |
| | 18 | 5:00 PM | vs. | Waubonsee Community College | L-70-100 | | | 36-65-4 |
| | 19 | 5:00 PM | vs. | Lake Forest College | L-69-82 | | | 36-66-4 |
| | | 7:30 PM | vs. | Illinois Institute of Technology | L-59-64 | | | 36-67-4 |
| | 21 | 3:00 PM | @ | Trinity Christian College | L-0-3 | | | 36-68-4 |
| | NCCAA Regional Tournament |
| | | 6:00 PM | vs. | Millikin University | L-54-61 (OT) | | | 36-69-4 |
| | TIU Classic |
| | | 8:00 PM | vs. | Indiana Wesleyan University | L-57-82 | | | 36-70-4 |
| | TIU Classic |
| | 22 | 6:00 PM | vs. | East-West University | W-83-76 | | | 37-70-4 |
| | TIU Classic |
| | 24 | 7:00 PM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | L-67-79 | | | 37-71-4 |
| | 25 | 6:00 PM | @ | Ashford University | W-77-73 | | | 38-71-4 |
| | 29 | 2:00 PM | vs. | Mount Vernon Nazarene College | L-49-75 | | | 38-72-4 |
| | Thanksgiving Classic |
| December |
| | 2 | 6:00 PM | vs. | Saint Xavier University | L-54-74 | | | 38-73-4 |
| | | 8:00 PM | vs. | St. Francis | L-66-70 | | | 38-74-4 |
| | 3 | 12:00 PM | vs. | Campbellsville University | L-1-2 | | | 38-75-4 |
| | NCCAA National Tournament - Kissimmee, FL December 2-6 |
| | | 2:30 PM | vs. | Asbury College | W-6-1 | | | 39-75-4 |
| | NCCAA National Tournament - Kissimmee, FL December 2-6 |
| | | 7:00 PM | vs. | Rock Valley College | L-74-78 | | | 39-76-4 |
| | 4 | 11:00 AM | vs. | Hope International University | W-3-1 | | | 40-76-4 |
| | NCCAA National Tournament - Kissimmee, FL Loser's Bracket |
| | | 1:30 PM | vs. | Olivet Nazarene University | L-1-4 | | | 40-77-4 |
| | NCCAA National Tournament - Kissimmee, FL Semi-Finals |
| | | 6:00 PM | @ | Indiana University-South Bend | W-71-67 | | | 41-77-4 |
| | | 7:00 PM | vs. | McHenry County College | L-72-87 | | | 41-78-4 |
| | 5 | 6:00 PM | vs. | Indiana University Northwest | W-86-56 | | | 42-78-4 |
| | Santa Lucia Classic |
| | | 6:00 PM | vs. | Asbury College | L-83-88 | | | 42-79-4 |
| | at Berea Classic |
| | 6 | 10:00 AM | vs. | Palm Beach Atlantic | L-1-4 | | | 42-80-4 |
| | NCCAA National Tournament - Kissimmee, FL 5th Place Game |
| | | 12:30 PM | vs. | Spring Arbor University | L-1-2 | | | 42-81-4 |
| | NCCAA National Tournament - Kissimmee, FL 3rd Place Game |
| | | 1:00 PM | vs. | Berea College | L-66-82 | | | 42-82-4 |
| | at Berea Classic |
| | | 2:00 PM | @ | North Park University | W-77-65 | | | 43-82-4 |
| | 8 | 7:00 PM | vs. | North Park University | CNCL | | | |
| | 9 | 6:00 PM | @ | Moody Bible Institute | W-73-37 | | | 44-82-4 |
| | | 7:00 PM | @ | Robert Morris University | L-68-96 | | | 44-83-4 |
| | Listen Live |
| | 11 | 7:00 PM | @ | Kishwaukee Community College | L-68-98 | | | 44-84-4 |
| | 12 | 6:00 PM | vs. | Hannibal-LaGrange University | W-79-66 | | | 45-84-4 |
| | | 6:00 PM | @ | Bethel College | L-77-102 | | | 45-85-4 |
| | Bethel IN Tourney |
| | 13 | 1:00 PM | @ | Ohio Dominican College | L-77-88 | | | 45-86-4 |
| | Bethel IN Tourney |
| | | 6:00 PM | vs. | Wilberforce University | W-82-68 | | | 46-86-4 |
| | 15 | 7:00 PM | @ | Saint Xavier University | L-71-115 | | | 46-87-4 |
| | 18 | 6:00 PM | @ | Huntington University | L-79-91 | | | 46-88-4 |
| % | 20 | 1:00 PM | @ | Silver Lake College | W-75-68 | | | |
| | 30 | 5:00 PM | vs. | Spring Arbor University | W-65-54 | | | 47-88-4 |
| January |
| | 2 | 7:00 PM | vs. | Mount Mercy University | L-89-90 (OT) | | | 47-89-4 |
| | Listen Live |
| | 5 | 5:00 PM | @ | Carthage College | CNCL | | | |
| | cancelled |
| | | 7:30 PM | @ | Carthage College | L-67-71 | | | 47-90-4 |
| | 6 | 4:00 PM | vs. | Daley College | L-44-96 | | | 47-91-4 |
| | | 6:00 PM | vs. | Olivet Nazarene University | W-107-95 | | | 48-91-4 |
| * | 12 | 1:00 PM | @ | Purdue University Calumet | W-88-76 | | | 49-91-4 18-16-2 |
| * | | 3:00 PM | @ | Purdue University Calumet | L-80-83 | | | 49-92-4 18-17-2 |
| * | 14 | 5:30 PM | @ | Cardinal Stritch University | L-61-82 | | | 49-93-4 18-18-2 |
| * | | 7:30 PM | @ | Cardinal Stritch University | L-73-82 | | | 49-94-4 18-19-2 |
| * | 17 | 7:30 PM | vs. | Purdue University-North Central | W-95-85 | | | 50-94-4 19-19-2 |
| * | 21 | 5:30 PM | vs. | Judson College | L-64-66 | | | 50-95-4 19-20-2 |
| * | | 7:30 PM | vs. | Judson College | L-71-86 | | | 50-96-4 19-21-2 |
| | Listen Live |
| * | 24 | 5:30 PM | vs. | Calumet College of St. Joseph | W-71-55 | | | 51-96-4 20-21-2 |
| * | | 7:30 PM | vs. | Calumet College of St. Joseph | W-66-56 | | | 52-96-4 21-21-2 |
| * | 28 | 5:30 PM | @ | Trinity Christian College | W-77-57 | | | 53-96-4 22-21-2 |
| * | | 7:30 PM | @ | Trinity Christian College | L-58-74 | | | 53-97-4 22-22-2 |
| | Listen Live |
| February |
| * | 4 | 5:30 PM | vs. | Purdue University Calumet | W-84-83 | | | 54-97-4 23-22-2 |
| * | | 7:30 PM | vs. | Purdue University Calumet | W-65-59 | | | 55-97-4 24-22-2 |
| * | 7 | 5:30 PM | vs. | Cardinal Stritch University | L-48-77 | | | 55-98-4 24-23-2 |
| * | | 7:30 PM | vs. | Cardinal Stritch University | L-75-91 | | | 55-99-4 24-24-2 |
| * | 11 | 7:00 PM | @ | Purdue University-North Central | W-78-76 (OT) | | | 56-99-4 25-24-2 |
| * | 14 | 5:30 PM | @ | Judson College | L-60-67 | | | 56-100-4 25-25-2 |
| * | | 7:00 PM | @ | Judson College | L-64-71 | | | 56-101-4 25-26-2 |
| * | 18 | 5:30 PM | @ | Calumet College of St. Joseph | W-63-51 | | | 57-101-4 26-26-2 |
| * | | 7:30 PM | @ | Calumet College of St. Joseph | L-62-69 | | | 57-102-4 26-27-2 |
| * | 21 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | W-59-56 | | | 58-102-4 27-27-2 |
| * | | 3:00 PM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | L-67-97 | | | 58-103-4 27-28-2 |
| | Listen Live |
| | 23 | 7:00 PM | @ | Calumet College of St. Joseph | W-90-67 | | | 59-103-4 |
| | CCAC Quarterfinals |
| | 24 | | vs. | Calumet College of St. Joseph | W-76-43 | | | 60-103-4 |
| | CCAC Quarterfinal |
| | 25 | 7:00 PM | @ | Cardinal Stritch University | L-55-74 | | | 60-104-4 |
| | CCAC Semi Final |
| | 26 | 7:00 PM | @ | Judson College | W-60-58 | | | 61-104-4 |
| | CCAC Semi Final |
| | 28 | | @ | Cardinal Stritch University | L-71-80 | | | 61-105-4 |
| | CCAC Final |
| March |
| | 3 | 4:00 PM | @ | San Francisco State University | RAIN | | | |
| | 4 | 1:00 PM | @ | Patten University | RAIN | | | |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Patten University | RAIN | | | |
| | 5 | 3:00 PM | @ | Bethany College | RAIN | | | |
| | 6 | 1:00 PM | @ | California State University-Hayward | L-1-22 | | | 61-106-4 |
| | | Game 2 | @ | California State University-Hayward | L-9-19 | | | 61-107-4 |
| | | 1:30 PM | @ | Siena Heights University | L-6-14 | | | 61-108-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | | 3:30 PM | @ | Viterbo University | W-11-3 | | | 62-108-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | 7 | 9:00 AM | @ | Patten University | L-1-9 | | | 62-109-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | | 11:00 AM | @ | Madonna University | L-0-11 | | | 62-110-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | | 1:00 PM | vs. | Northwestern College | W-59-53 | | | 63-110-4 |
| | NCCAA Regional Tournament |
| | | 1:00 PM | @ | Academy of Art University | RAIN | | | |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Academy of Art University | RAIN | | | |
| | | 3:30 PM | @ | Aquinas College | L-6-15 | | | 63-111-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | 9 | 9:00 AM | @ | Peru State College | L-5-9 | | | 63-112-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | | 11:00 AM | @ | University of Great Falls | L-1-14 | | | 63-113-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | | 3:30 PM | @ | Waldorf College | L-0-9 | | | 63-114-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | | 4:00 PM | @ | La Sierra University | W-24-6 | | | 64-114-4 |
| | 10 | 9:00 AM | @ | Aquinas College | L-1-9 | | | 64-115-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | | 11:00 AM | @ | Jamestown College | L-3-13 | | | 64-116-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | | 5:00 PM | @ | Azusa Pacific University | L-2-16 | | | 64-117-4 |
| | 11 | 10:30 AM | @ | Northwestern College | W-14-4 | | | 65-117-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | | 1:00 PM | @ | California State University-San Marcos | L-3-4 | | | 65-118-4 |
| | | 1:00 PM | @ | Mount Marty College | W-11-5 | | | 66-118-4 |
| | Tucson, AZ |
| | 12 | 3:00 PM | vs. | Palm Beach Atlantic | L-48-55 | | | 66-119-4 |
| | NCCAA National Tournament First Round |
| | | 4:30 PM | @ | Vanguard University | L-2-22 | | | 66-120-4 |
| | 13 | 2:00 PM | vs. | Grace College | L-50-85 | | | 66-121-4 |
| | NCCAA National Tournamnet Consolation Round |
| | | 3:00 PM | @ | Westmont College | L-1-5 | | | 66-122-4 |
| | 14 | 9:00 AM | vs. | Oakland City University | L-39-64 | | | 66-123-4 |
| | NCCAA National Tournament 7th Place Game |
| | 17 | 3:30 PM | @ | Saint Ambrose University | L-2-16 | | | 66-124-4 |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Saint Ambrose University | L-0-8 | | | 66-125-4 |
| * | 20 | 3:30 PM | @ | Robert Morris University | W-7-2 | | | 67-125-4 28-28-2 |
| * | 21 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Robert Morris University | W-4-3 | | | 68-125-4 29-28-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Robert Morris University | L-0-10 | | | 68-126-4 29-29-2 |
| * | 24 | 1:00 PM | @ | Trinity Christian College | L-10-13 | | | 68-127-4 29-30-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Trinity Christian College | W-18-9 | | | 69-127-4 30-30-2 |
| * | | 3:00 PM | @ | Calumet College of St. Joseph | RAIN | | | |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Calumet College of St. Joseph | RAIN | | | |
| | 27 | 3:00 PM | vs. | Carthage College | L-0-7 | | | 69-128-4 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Carthage College | L-2-7 | | | 69-129-4 |
| * | | 3:30 PM | vs. | University of Saint Francis | L-7-11 | | | 69-130-4 30-31-2 |
| * | 28 | 12:00 PM | vs. | Purdue University-North Central | L-0-10 | | | 69-131-4 30-32-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Purdue University-North Central | L-2-10 | | | 69-132-4 30-33-2 |
| | | 12:00 PM | @ | University of Saint Francis | RAIN | | | |
| | Game moved to 3/30/09 |
| | | Game 2 | @ | University of Saint Francis | RAIN | | | |
| | Game Moved to 3/30/09 |
| * | 30 | 2:00 PM | @ | University of Saint Francis | RAIN | | | |
| | Make up from 3/28/09 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | University of Saint Francis | RAIN | | | |
| | 31 | 3:00 PM | @ | Cardinal Stritch University | RAIN | | | |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Cardinal Stritch University | RAIN | | | |
| April |
| * | 1 | 3:00 PM | @ | Calumet College of St. Joseph | L-6-17 | | | 69-133-4 30-34-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Calumet College of St. Joseph | L-1-9 | | | 69-134-4 30-35-2 |
| * | | 3:30 PM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | RAIN | | | |
| * | 2 | 3:00 PM | vs. | Saint Xavier University | L-0-9 | | | 69-135-4 30-36-2 |
| * | | 3:30 PM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | L-1-7 | | | 69-136-4 30-37-2 |
| | Make Up from 4/1/09 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Saint Xavier University | L-1-6 | | | 69-137-4 30-38-2 |
| | 3 | 1:45 PM | vs. | Bethel College | L-0-14 | | | 69-138-4 |
| | Judson Tournament |
| | | 3:30 PM | vs. | Huntington University | L-2-8 | | | 69-139-4 |
| | Judson Tournament |
| * | | 3:30 PM | @ | Saint Xavier University | L-11-17 | | | 69-140-4 30-39-2 |
| * | 4 | 12:00 PM | @ | Saint Xavier University | L-0-10 | | | 69-141-4 30-40-2 |
| | Game moved to St. Xavier due to field conditions |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Saint Xavier University | L-1-11 | | | 69-142-4 30-41-2 |
| | | 4:00 PM | vs. | Bethel College | L-0-17 | | | 69-143-4 |
| | Judson Tournament |
| | | 5:45 PM | vs. | Judson College | L-4-12 | | | 69-144-4 |
| | Judson Tournament |
| * | 7 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Judson College | RAIN | | | |
| | Moved to 4/8/09 |
| * | | 5:00 PM | @ | Judson College | L-1-13 | | | 69-145-4 30-42-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Judson College | W-5-4 | | | 70-145-4 31-42-2 |
| * | 8 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Judson College | L-2-4 | | | 70-146-4 31-43-2 |
| | Make-Up from 4/7/09 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Judson College | L-0-4 | | | 70-147-4 31-44-2 |
| | Make-Up from 4/7/09 |
| * | 9 | 3:00 PM | vs. | Olivet Nazarene University | L-4-6 | | | 70-148-4 31-45-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Olivet Nazarene University | W-6-3 | | | 71-148-4 32-45-2 |
| | 10 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Hannibal-LaGrange University | L-1-11 | | | 71-149-4 |
| | Iowa Wesleyan Tournament |
| | | 3:00 PM | vs. | Lindenwood University | L-0-25 | | | 71-150-4 |
| | Iowa Wesleyan Tournament |
| * | | 3:30 PM | vs. | Purdue University-North Central | L-6-7 | | | 71-151-4 32-46-2 |
| | | 5:00 PM | vs. | Saint Ambrose University | L-1-8 | | | 71-152-4 |
| | Iowa Wesleyan Tournament |
| | 11 | 11:00 AM | vs. | Harris-Stowe State College | L-5-8 | | | 71-153-4 |
| | Iowa Wesleyan Tournament |
| * | | 12:00 PM | @ | Purdue University-North Central | L-2-8 | | | 71-154-4 32-47-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Purdue University-North Central | L-0-4 | | | 71-155-4 32-48-2 |
| | | 1:00 PM | vs. | Lindenwood University | L-1-9 | | | 71-156-4 |
| | Iowa Wesleyan Tournament |
| | 13 | 1:00 PM | @ | Lincoln Christian University | RAIN | | | |
| | Rescheduled for 4/23/09 |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Lincoln Christian University | RAIN | | | |
| | Rescheduled for 4/23/09 |
| | 14 | 3:30 PM | @ | Northwestern University | L-6-15 | | | 71-157-4 |
| * | | 5:00 PM | @ | University of Saint Francis | L-2-18 | | | 71-158-4 32-49-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | University of Saint Francis | L-3-7 | | | 71-159-4 32-50-2 |
| * | 15 | 4:00 PM | @ | Judson College | L-4-8 | | | 71-160-4 32-51-2 |
| * | 17 | 3:30 PM | @ | Illinois Institute of Technology | W-8-7 | | | 72-160-4 33-51-2 |
| * | 18 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Illinois Institute of Technology | L-3-5 (9) | | | 72-161-4 33-52-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Illinois Institute of Technology | L-4-5 | | | 72-162-4 33-53-2 |
| * | 21 | 3:00 PM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | RAIN | | | |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Trinity Christian College | RAIN | | | |
| * | 22 | 1:00 PM | @ | Cardinal Stritch University | W-17-0 | | | 73-162-4 34-53-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Cardinal Stritch University | W-8-6 | | | 74-162-4 35-53-2 |
| * | 23 | 3:00 PM | vs. | Robert Morris University | L-1-10 | | | 74-163-4 35-54-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Robert Morris University | L-0-4 | | | 74-164-4 35-55-2 |
| * | 24 | 3:00 PM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | W-7-1 | | | 75-164-4 36-55-2 |
| | Make Up from 4/21/09 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Trinity Christian College | L-4-8 | | | 75-165-4 36-56-2 |
| * | | 3:30 PM | vs. | Calumet College of St. Joseph | W-3-0 | | | 76-165-4 37-56-2 |
| * | 25 | 1:00 PM | @ | Calumet College of St. Joseph | W-12-0 | | | 77-165-4 38-56-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Calumet College of St. Joseph | L-6-10 | | | 77-166-4 38-57-2 |
| * | 27 | 2:00 PM | @ | University of Saint Francis | RAIN | | | |
| | Make Up from 4/6/09 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | University of Saint Francis | RAIN | | | |
| | Make Up from 4/6/09 |
| * | 28 | 3:00 PM | @ | University of Saint Francis | W-1-0 (8) | | | 78-166-4 39-57-2 |
| | Make Up From April 27 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | University of Saint Francis | L-0-9 | | | 78-167-4 39-58-2 |
| | Make Up from April 27 |
| * | 29 | 3:30 PM | vs. | Cardinal Stritch University | W-13-1 (7) | | | 79-167-4 40-58-2 |
| May |
| * | 1 | 3:30 PM | @ | Olivet Nazarene University | L-1-12 | | | 79-168-4 40-59-2 |
| * | 2 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Olivet Nazarene University | L-8-10 | | | 79-169-4 40-60-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Olivet Nazarene University | L-2-6 | | | 79-170-4 40-61-2 |
| | 5 | 7:30 PM | @ | University of Illinois - Chicago | L-0-14 | | | 79-171-4 |
| | 7 | 2:00 PM | vs. | Finlandia University | W-16-1 | | | 80-171-4 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Finlandia University | W-5-3 | | | 81-171-4 |
| | 8 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Finlandia University | W-21-6 | | | 82-171-4 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Finlandia University | W-25-2 | | | 83-171-4 |
| | 9 | 1:00 PM | vs. | Finlandia University | W-15-0 | | | 84-171-4 |